Senior Pastors
| Rev. Charles Carhart | 1914-1922 |
| Rev. Robert Russell | 1922-1939 |
| Rev. Floyd McGuire | 1940-1964 |
| Rev. James Emerson | 1965-1969 |
| Rev. Calvin DeVries | 1970-1977 |
| Rev. Richard Martin | 1978-1997 |
| Rev. William Crawford | 1999-2018 |
| Rev. Dr. Peter Bynum | 2021-Present |
Associate Pastors
| Rev. Frank Shumway | 1932 |
| Rev. Herbert Landes | 1946 |
| Rev. Vincent Stratton | 1950-1953 |
| Rev. David Blackshear | 1953 |
| Rev. Peter Sherrard | 1967-1969 |
| Rev. Tom Wedsworth | 1966-1969 |
| Rev. Gary Hall | 1971-1978 |
| Rev. Michael Drake | 1981-1994 |
| Rev. Michael Nelms | 1995-1998 |
| Rev. Jed Koball | 2000-2002 |
| Rev. Andrew Kort | 2003-2005 |
| Rev. Jed Koball | 2008-2008 (interim) |
| Rev. Julie Emery | 2008-2014 |
| Rev. Elizabeth Smith-Bartlett | 2014-2020 |
| Rev. Anna Grace Claunch | 2022-Present |